The People's Government: Investigation Into Federal Privatization, Private Control, and the Transfer of Public Authority
Who Owns the Infrastructure, Who Controls the Decisions, and Who Answers to the American People?
The American people deserve to know who owns the infrastructure operating in their name, who controls essential governmental functions, and whether public authority remains accountable under the Constitution and federal law.
1. Case overview
This is an organized, transparent investigation into whether any federal agency, official, or contractor has participated in arrangements that unlawfully transfer governmental authority, conceal material changes in public operational control, evade statutory oversight, or cause legally actionable harm through privatization or contracting. It also examines whether lawful arrangements nonetheless create serious accountability or continuity risks.
Core principle
Public contracting is not inherently unlawful. But a government cannot use private contracting to evade constitutional limits, statutory duties, public accountability, or restrictions on the delegation of governmental authority.
The investigation does not presume that privatization is illegal, does not presume a coordinated scheme, and will remain open to evidence that contradicts its starting questions.
2. Why this investigation matters
Americans on social media and elsewhere are asking whether public institutions are being allowed to fail so that they can be handed to private interests. That is a serious question. It is also, at this point, a hypothesis and not an established fact. The responsible response is to examine the records.
When infrastructure, software, data, or day-to-day operations of an essential service sit in private hands, the public may not be able to tell who is in control, whether the government could keep the service running without a particular company, or who answers when it fails. Those questions can be answered with documents.
3. Verified factual background
- VerifiedE-001
On November 17, 2026, the Secretary of Transportation, the OMB Director, and the FAA Administrator asked the House and Senate Appropriations Committees for $50.1 billion for air traffic control modernization and airport infrastructure. The letter breaks down spending but does not address who will own or operate the new systems.
- VerifiedE-003
On November 13, 2026, the FAA issued a nationwide ground stop. The FAA states that legacy equipment became unstable when data flooded the FAA Telecommunications Infrastructure network, affecting 17 of 22 en route centers. The root-cause investigation was ongoing.
- VerifiedE-004
In September 2026, GAO reported that the Brand New Air Traffic Control System program lacked a reliable lifecycle cost estimate and an integrated master schedule.
- VerifiedE-002
Project 2025’s Department of Transportation chapter recommends separating the FAA from DOT or, at a minimum, the Air Traffic Organization from the FAA, funding air traffic services through user fees, and operating the FAA more like a business. It describes these as changes requiring legislation. These are proposals; no action implementing them has been identified.
- VerifiedE-007, E-016
The FAA has contracted out the staffing of some control towers since 1982 under a program Congress authorizes and funds. In May 2026 the FAA began a pilot moving selected high-activity contract towers into FAA operation.
4. FAA pilot investigation
Air traffic control is the first example because the records are identifiable: a large modernization program, a prime integrator, contractor-run telecommunications networks, a long-standing contract tower program, and recent GAO and Inspector General work. Naming a contract or company here records a public fact. It is not an allegation.
Dated chronology
| Date | Event | Category | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1982 | FAA Contract Tower Program established | Implemented change (authorized) | Verified |
| 2002 | FAA Telecommunications Infrastructure contract awarded to Harris Corp. (now L3Harris) | Executed contract | Verified |
| Mar. 2023 | FAA Enterprise Network Services awarded to Verizon | Executed contract | Verified |
| Apr. 2023 | Project 2025 Mandate for Leadership published | Policy proposal | Verified |
| May 16, 2024 | FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 directs a contract tower conversion pilot | Enacted legislation | Verified |
| May 8, 2025 | Brand New Air Traffic Control System announced | Official announcement | Verified |
| July 4, 2025 | $12.5 billion provided for ATC modernization | Appropriated funding | Verified |
| Dec. 4, 2025 | Peraton announced as prime integrator | Executed contract | Under investigation |
| May 18, 2026 | Pilot moves selected contract towers to FAA staffing | Implemented change (toward federal operation) | Verified |
| Aug. 11, 2026 | AT&T awarded lead role on FAA Enterprise Network Services; Verizon moves to support | Executed contract | Under investigation |
| Aug. 2026 | Press reports of FAA concerns about the integrator’s performance | Reported, not adjudicated | Unverified |
| Sept. 14, 2026 | GAO-26-107992 issued | Oversight finding | Verified |
| Nov. 13, 2026 | Nationwide ground stop | Documented service disruption | Verified |
| Nov. 17, 2026 | $50.1 billion request to Congress | Official announcement (request) | Verified |
A proposed reform is never described as an implemented transfer without evidence. The hypothesis that air traffic control is being allowed to deteriorate to justify privatization is labeled Unverified: no supporting record has been identified.
Ownership-and-control map
| Layer | What the public record shows | What we are working to verify |
|---|---|---|
| Equipment | FAA owns most airspace-system facilities; the request funds up to 140 FAA-owned towers | Title to new equipment; anything leased or provided as a service |
| Software | $7.2 billion requested for a common automation platform and controller workstations | Who owns the code; license, escrow, and modification rights |
| Communications | Contractor-run networks carry airspace-system data and voice | Whether the network is contractor-owned; FAA step-in and data rights |
| Operational data | Not addressed in the records reviewed | Who holds and can export flight, surveillance, and system data |
| Workforce | FAA controllers at FAA facilities; contractor controllers at contract towers | Role of integrator staff in decisions |
| Decision authority | Federal law vests airspace authority in the FAA Administrator | Delegations in the integrator contract; who approves design and acceptance |
5. Questions under investigation
- Has any federal agency transferred a governmental function, or the operational control of essential infrastructure, without the authority the law requires?
- Do contractors make, or effectively make, final decisions that bind the public or commit federal funds?
- Who owns the equipment, software, and data that essential public functions depend on, and could the government replace the contractor without loss of service?
- Who ultimately owns and controls the contractors performing essential functions, and is control concentrated across agencies?
- Were required notices, records, legal reviews, or approvals omitted or bypassed?
- Has any identifiable person suffered a concrete, legally cognizable harm traceable to an unlawful arrangement?
Six investigative tracks
Track A
Changes in governmental authority
Which functions were transferred, delegated, contracted, or reorganized; under what statute; whether Congress authorized it; whether officials kept required supervision; whether it was disclosed.
Track B
Ownership of essential public infrastructure
Who owns equipment, software, communications systems, facilities, and data, and whether ownership limits the government’s ability to replace a contractor.
Track C
Contractor and beneficial-ownership structures
Direct, indirect, and beneficial ownership; voting, contractual, and operational control; passive investment and common institutional ownership, recorded without inferring coordination.
Track D
Procurement and financial arrangements
Awards, competition, sole-source justifications, modifications, long-term obligations, pricing, performance, conflicts, termination and step-in rights, and audit access.
Track E
Public harm and operational dependence
Documented service disruptions, cost increases, loss of capability, unlawful employment actions, security failures, and records access, kept separate from speculative risk.
Track F
Concealment and accountability
Whether required records, disclosures, oversight steps, or approvals were omitted, withheld, or bypassed. Lawful confidentiality is not treated as concealment.
6. Relevant constitutional and statutory law
- Article I gives Congress the legislative power and the power of the purse. Agencies may not spend money for purposes Congress has not approved or restructure statutory agencies without legislation.
- Article II vests executive power in the President, who must faithfully execute the laws. The Appointments Clause requires that people exercising significant federal authority be properly appointed officers.
- Private nondelegation. Carter v. Carter Coal Co. (1936) struck down private control of binding industry rules. Sunshine Anthracite (1940) upheld private participation where the government kept final authority. In FCC v. Consumers' Research (2025), the Supreme Court found no violation because the FCC retained final decision-making power.
- Inherently governmental functions. The FAIR Act, OMB Policy Letter 11-01, and FAR Subpart 7.5 bar contracting out functions that must be performed by federal employees. The FAA generally uses its own acquisition system rather than the FAR.
- Administrative Procedure Act. Allows courts to set aside final agency action that is unlawful or arbitrary, if a plaintiff with a concrete injury brings the case.
- Transparency and oversight. FOIA, the Federal Records Act, the Inspector General Act, and whistleblower protections for federal and contractor employees.
- Ninth Amendment. It states that listing certain rights does not deny others retained by the people. Courts have not treated it as an independent source of enforceable rights or a cause of action, and it does not by itself give anyone standing to sue. This investigation relies on recognized statutory and constitutional claims, if the evidence supports any.
7. Federal contracting and privatization distinctions
| Arrangement | What it means | General status |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary procurement | The government buys goods or routine services and keeps every decision. | Lawful and common |
| Contractor-operated support | Contractor staff do support work under federal direction. | Lawful; watch for inherently governmental work |
| Government-owned, contractor-operated | The government owns the asset; a contractor runs it. | Lawful; dependency depends on rights retained |
| Contractor-owned, contractor-operated | A contractor owns and runs infrastructure an essential function depends on. | Lawful in many cases; highest dependency risk |
| Delegation of authority | A private party makes or effectively makes binding public decisions. | Constitutional and statutory limits apply |
| Full privatization of a function | Responsibility moves to a non-federal entity. | Generally requires legislation |
Ownership is not the same as operational control, and neither is the same as decision authority. Private equity sponsorship, institutional investment, or shared ownership is recorded for transparency and is not treated as evidence of misconduct.
8. Evidence register
Every factual statement on this page is tied to a record in the evidence register, with its issuer, date, what it does and does not show, and its authentication status. Official sources (Congress.gov, the Federal Register, USAspending.gov, SAM.gov, GAO, Inspectors General, court filings, and SEC filings) are prioritized. News reporting is used as corroboration. Social media posts and public submissions are leads, not proof.
The full register is maintained in the investigation file and will be published with each update. Selected records are listed under Sources below.
9. Documented findings
Verified The records establish the funding request, the ground stop and the FAA's initial explanation, GAO's cost and schedule findings, the content of the Project 2025 proposals, and the long-standing, statutorily authorized contract tower program.
No record reviewed to date establishes that any agency, official, or company has acted unlawfully.
10. Allegations requiring verification
- UnverifiedThat public institutions are being deliberately allowed to deteriorate to justify privatization.
- UnverifiedPress reports of FAA concerns about the prime integrator's performance (August 2026).
- Legally unresolvedWhether any contractor in the modernization program makes final decisions that bind the public.
11. Potential public harms
Documented: the November 13, 2026 nationwide ground stop disrupted air travel. Its root cause, and whether any contract arrangement contributed, are not established.
Risks under investigation, which are not injuries unless proven:
- loss of the government's ability to operate essential systems without a particular contractor;
- vendor lock-in and higher long-term taxpayer cost;
- improper exercise of governmental authority by private parties;
- concentration of control across essential services;
- loss of public access to records held by contractors;
- security and continuity failures.
12. Government and contractor responses
We invite the Department of Transportation, the FAA, and any company named on this page to respond, correct, or add context. Responses received will be published here in full or summarized fairly, with the date received.
No responses have been received as of November 18, 2026.
13. Legal analysis
Every potential theory is currently unproven. Under current precedent, a private-delegation claim would require evidence that a contractor makes final, binding decisions without meaningful federal review, and the Supreme Court's 2025 decision makes that a demanding standard. An APA claim would require a final agency action and a plaintiff with a concrete injury. Procurement protests are limited to bidders. Records-access claims under FOIA are the most likely near-term legal pathway.
Strongest counterarguments
- Most federal contracting is lawful, and the FAA retains statutory authority over the airspace.
- Modernization through contractors is not privatization; the request funds FAA-owned towers.
- The FAA is moving some contract towers into federal operation, which cuts against the privatization hypothesis.
- Project 2025 proposals require legislation, and none has been identified as implemented.
- Standing, ripeness, and sovereign immunity significantly limit litigation by members of the public.
Remedies and accountability pathways
| Pathway | What the law requires | Status |
|---|---|---|
| FOIA requests | A specific, reasonably described request; exemptions may apply | Being prepared |
| Inspector General referral | Specific information suggesting possible waste, fraud, abuse, or violation of law | Only if warranted |
| GAO review request | Generally made by a congressional committee or member | Possible |
| Congressional oversight request | Questions directed to committees of jurisdiction | Being prepared |
| Procurement protest | Only actual or prospective bidders; strict deadlines; FAA uses its own dispute office | Not available to this organization as a non-bidder |
| Judicial review under the APA | Final agency action, a plaintiff with a concrete injury, and a reviewable legal violation | Not ripe; no action or plaintiff identified |
| Injunctive or declaratory relief | Standing, a likely legal violation, and equitable factors | Not ripe |
Courts cannot automatically invalidate privatization. Each remedy has its own legal requirements.
14. Public participation
If you are a federal employee, contractor employee, air traffic controller, technician, small business, or member of the public with documented information about federal privatization, contractor control, agency restructuring, infrastructure ownership, or related harm, you can submit it for review.
- Do not submit classified information, unlawfully obtained records, credentials, or other people's private information.
- We cannot promise anonymity, privilege, immunity, or whistleblower protection.
- Employees seeking legal protection for disclosures should consider their agency Inspector General, the U.S. Office of Special Counsel, or Congress.
- Every submission is treated as a lead to be checked, never as a verified allegation.
15. Investigation timeline
- Preserve and hash every cited record.
- File records requests for the integrator contract, the network contracts, the ground stop root-cause analysis, and any restructuring studies.
- Open public intake after privacy and security review.
- Build the ownership-and-control map from the records received.
- Re-evaluate every legal theory against the evidence.
- Pursue oversight, referral, or legal action only where the evidence and the law support it.
16. Current status and next steps
Status: Pre-Litigation Investigation · Evidence Gathering / Legal Review Required. No complaint has been filed. No defendants or plaintiffs have been identified. This page will be updated as records arrive, and corrections will be labeled and dated.
17. Sources and methodology
- E-001U.S. DOT, OMB, FAA — Joint Letter Regarding Additional ATC Funding (Nov. 17, 2026)
- E-002The Heritage Foundation — Mandate for Leadership 2025, Ch. 19, pp. 632–634
- E-003FAA — Nationwide Ground Stop: Questions and Answers (Nov. 15, 2026)
- E-004U.S. GAO — GAO-26-107992, Air Traffic Control Systems (Sept. 14, 2026)
- E-005Congressional Research Service — The Private Nondelegation Doctrine, IF13307 (Sept. 8, 2026)
- E-006Congressional Research Service — FCC v. Consumers' Research, LSB11301
- E-007FAA — Contract Tower Program
- E-008Federal Acquisition Regulation — Subpart 7.5, Inherently Governmental Functions
- E-010AIN — FAA Awards ATC Upgrade Integration Contract to Peraton (Dec. 5, 2025)
- E-014Washington Technology — FAA brings in AT&T for network modernization program (Aug. 2026)
- E-016FAA — Pilot to transition selected contract towers to FAA operation (May 18, 2026)
- E-019Ballard Spahr — FinCEN exempts U.S. entities from beneficial ownership reporting (Aug. 24, 2026)
Method: records are classified by what each party actually owns, controls, and decides; legal authority is matched to statute, appropriation, and contract; ownership is traced through lawful records; and patterns across agencies are evaluated with published criteria. A repeated pattern does not by itself establish intent, collusion, or unlawful coordination.
Important legal notice
This page announces an evidence-gathering and legal-review initiative. It is not a lawsuit, does not state that any agency, official, or company has acted unlawfully, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statements about contracts and ownership reflect public records cited above. Anyone with an active legal deadline should consult qualified counsel without waiting for this investigation.