Site is under construction - will be ready soon
The People’s Docket

Kelo v. City of New London and the Meaning of Public Use

Constitutional precedent review and proposals for public discussion

What the Court decided

The Fifth Amendment says private property shall not “be taken for public use, without just compensation.” In Kelo v. City of New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005), the Supreme Court held 5–4 that New London’s integrated economic redevelopment plan served a public purpose sufficient to satisfy the federal public-use requirement, even though some of the property would pass to private parties. The majority followed precedents interpreting public use broadly and evaluated the planned development as a whole. It also recognized a limit on takings that use a public purpose as a pretext to confer a private benefit.

Justice O’Connor warned that expected economic gains could leave ordinary property owners vulnerable to takings for the benefit of more influential private interests. Justice Thomas argued that the clause requires government ownership or a legal right for the public to use the property. Read the majority opinion, concurrence, and dissents.

Why the distinction matters

A projected increase in jobs or tax revenue tells the public what a developer expects to deliver. A legal right of public access or an enforceable duty to serve the public tells people what they can actually demand. When a project seeks to force an easement across a working farm, the public record should explain who the project is designed to serve, why that route is needed, and how it would affect irrigation, equipment access, and food production. Federal transmission condemnation also has its own statutory requirements.Read 16 U.S.C. § 824p.

Protect farmland for future generations

Proposed rule: Prohibit eminent domain on land in agricultural production or capable of agricultural production. The prohibition would cover the land itself and compulsory easements and rights-of-way. It would apply to public agencies and private entities exercising delegated authority, including for airports, transmission lines, and infrastructure serving data centers. A community vote or regional infrastructure exception could not override this protection.

Buildings and pavement can take soil out of agricultural use. Construction can also remove or mix topsoil and compact the layers below it, limiting root growth and water infiltration. Iowa State University researchers documented soil compaction and gradual crop yield recovery over five years after pipeline construction on farmland. Preserving productive land today protects the ability of future generations to grow food.

Determine agricultural capability using soil surveys, local production history, and site conditions, with input from farmers and farm tenants. Land that is temporarily fallow or in crop rotation would remain eligible for protection.

What happens if we ignore farmland loss?

A runway or building can take productive soil out of use for decades, and some conversions can be irreversible. Even an easement that leaves most of a farm intact can interrupt irrigation, cut off equipment access, or reduce yields after construction. The loss can extend beyond the acres inside the project boundary if the remaining land becomes harder to farm.

When agencies consider one parcel at a time, they can miss what several projects together do to a farming region. Successive takings can leave fewer connected fields and fewer viable places to grow food. That leaves future farmers with fewer options when drought or floods limit what other fields can produce.

A compensation payment addresses the property taken. It does not restore the region’s capacity to grow food. Before a route or site is chosen, the public record should show what would happen to the whole farm, how the project adds to other farmland losses in the area, and which feasible sites or routes avoid farmable land. Farmers and farm tenants should help identify those effects while alternatives are still open.

Safeguards for public discussion

  • Require a demonstrable public use or enforceable duty to serve the public. Economic projections alone would be insufficient.
  • Disclose who ultimately owns and controls the applicant, which major customers the project is designed to serve, and what feasible routes were evaluated.

States may adopt stronger safeguards. Michigan’s constitution excludes takings for transfer to a private entity for economic development or increased tax revenue from its definition of public use.Read Michigan Constitution Article X, Section 2.

What happens when the community votes no?

Existing federal transmission law gives affected landowners and other interested people a reasonable opportunity to present their views. A binding vote would require a change to the law governing the taking, including federal law where federal condemnation authority applies.Read 16 U.S.C. § 824p(d)–(e).

  • Before the vote, publish the route, land impacts, ownership, intended beneficiaries, and feasible alternatives. Give each directly affected community a separate vote so residents elsewhere cannot outvote the people who would bear the direct impacts.
  • If any directly affected community votes no, block condemnation for that route when the project primarily serves an identified private development. A substantially revised route would require new notice and approval from the communities it would affect.
  • For essential regional infrastructure outside protected farmland, consider a narrow exception. Require the condemning authority to prove by clear and convincing evidence in court that the project meets an essential public need and that no feasible, less harmful route exists. Give affected people a chance to challenge the evidence and block any taking while the court decides.
  • Preserve each owner’s right to challenge the taking of their parcel and seek just compensation even after a yes vote. Give farm tenants a separate opportunity to document how a taking would affect their operations.

Before settling the proposal, ask affected residents, landowners, farm tenants, and Tribal governments how to draw voting boundaries, who should vote, and whether any override should exist. Preserve Tribal governments’ separate decision-making authority wherever it applies.